How to Give Effective Feedback to Your Mentee

« Back to Articles

When it comes to being a mentor, it’s fair to say that one of the most beneficial skills to have is the ability to provide great feedback. Feedback is an extremely powerful tool in all relationships, both personal and professional but is particularly useful when it comes to building great mentoring relationships.

Feedback is the perfect way to help a mentee improve, grow and reflect, providing valuable insights and perspectives to help a mentee develop and accomplish their objectives.

In this article, we will discuss the importance of providing feedback and share 7 tips on how you can give constructive feedback to set your mentee up for success.

The Importance of Providing Your Mentee with Feedback

Constructive feedback is extremely impactful for mentees, influencing their overall behaviour and success. Feedback is the first step in helping your mentee make the positive changes they need to reach their goals, encouraging them to seek new opportunities and take on the challenges they face. Here are 5 reasons why you should be providing feedback to your mentee:

1. Feedback Helps Build a Stronger Relationship

One of the key aspects of mentoring is building a strong relationship. A good mentoring relationship is built on trust and respect and so building a strong relationship is key. By providing effective feedback to your mentee, you promote open communication and help build trust. If the feedback is practical and given respectfully, it helps create an environment where your mentee will be more honest and transparent with you, which will result in a stronger mentoring relationship.

2. Feedback Builds a Foundation for Growth

Feedback in a mentoring relationship plays a crucial role in building a foundation for growth and improvement. When you provide your mentee with feedback, you’re offering them a fresh perspective on things such as their performance and areas for improvement. When you identify these things, you’re able to help the mentee better understand where they need to focus their efforts if they want to develop professionally. As a mentor, it’s your role to equip the mentee with the information they need to grow and make better decisions.

3. Feedback Keeps Your Mentee Motivated

Feedback isn’t just about focusing on the things an individual needs to improve upon, it’s also about highlighting the areas in which the individual is doing great. Unsurprisingly, this can help your mentee feel more motivated. When the mentee has a better understanding of their strengths they can use this to their advantage. Recognition will make your mentee feel more accomplished and motivated to continue striving for success.

4. Feedback Helps Your Mentee Develop a Growth Mindset

When you provide constructive feedback to your mentees, it helps them develop a growth mindset. Feedback encourages your mentee to take on new challenges and continuously strive for improvement, something that is needed when an individual wants to reach their goals and grow. It helps teach the mentee that sometimes setbacks are the first steps to success.

5. Feedback Encourages Self-Reflection and Evaluation

When you provide your mentees with constructive feedback, it encourages them to take a deeper look at themselves and engage in reflective practices. Feedback promotes your mentee to assess their performance, identify any behaviours they have and evaluate their progress. This not only encourages reflection but empowers your mentee to take ownership of their learning and development journey.

7 Tips For Delivering Great Feedback to Mentees

Providing great feedback is an art. It requires skill, compassion and also strategic communication. If you want to provide your mentee with the most effective feedback, here are a few tips you can consider:

1. Build Trust

As mentioned, feedback is a great way to build trust within a mentoring relationship. However, before you start giving feedback straight away, you need to establish a foundation of trust and rapport. You must create a supportive environment where the feedback you provide is received open-mindedly and willingly.

2. Be Specific

When you offer feedback to your mentee, you need to be specific. When you offer general comments it can be confusing for your mentee. You need to be specific about what you’re addressing, this will help your mentee think of the feedback as fair and allow them to put a plan in place.

3. Use a Positive Tone

Whenever you provide feedback to your mentees you need to ensure you keep a positive tone. When you frame your feedback positively and engagingly, it will help the mentee receive the feedback better. Even if the feedback is an area of improvement, the communication tone you use will greatly influence the outcome.

4. Be Balanced

While it’s important to address areas of improvement, it’s also essential that you recognise the strengths and accomplishments of your mentee. As well as keeping a positive tone, it’s important that you balance any criticism with praise. This will help keep your mentee motivated and also boost their confidence.

5. Make Responses Timely

When providing feedback to your mentee, you need to provide it promptly, after you’ve observed a specific behaviour or performance. When you have regular check-ins and feedback sessions with your mentee, it will not only help your mentee keep on track to reaching their goals but allow you to provide feedback regularly.

6. Focus on Behaviour

When you provide feedback to your mentee, make sure you focus on behaviours and not their personality or characteristics. When your mentee feels judged on a personal level, they might feel offended which will impact the relationship as a whole. By focusing on behaviours, your mentee will be able to better understand the impact of their actions.

7. Encourage Two-Way Feedback

Whilst it’s important to give your mentee, it’s also vital to encourage two-way feedback. Creating a relationship where your mentee is open to not only receiving feedback but also giving it, encourages mutual learning from both parties and will help intensify the mentorship bond.

Final Thoughts

Mentorship is a mutual learning experience focused on guidance, support and growth. By providing your mentees with the feedback they need effectively, you’re helping set your mentees up for success and to reach their full potential.

Use these tips the next time you plan to give your mentee feedback to help them reflect, learn and evolve.