The Pros and Cons of Job Hopping (Guide For Recruiters and Job Seekers)

« Back to Articles

There was a time when the ‘ideal’ career was pretty simple: get yourself into a good job, stay with it, get on, and finally retire from it to receive a gold watch and that nice pension. But is this still the case today? Let’s talk about the rising trend of job hopping.

What is Job Hopping?

Job hopping, typically defined by one to two year stints with different employers, is becoming a more common trend.

Job hopping is a double-edged sword. As a job seeker, it provides the opportunity to move up the ladder quickly, diversify their skills, and find the role that’s a perfect fit. But, at the same time, candidates need to take care that their job hopping doesn’t make them appear unreliable or uncommitted.

So, what's with all the job-hopping? Is it a red flag to employers of a fickle, impatient, and disloyal employee, or is it an ambitious and valuable career strategy?

Job Hopping Pros for Hiring Candidates

Listed below are some of the benefits of job jopping for hiring candidates.

1. Fuels career progression by embracing new challenges

Sometimes, you need to try on a few pairs of shoes before you find the right fit. Equally, people change jobs to allow themselves to experience different roles, companies, and industries, to find something that genuinely fits.

2. Broadens professional networks and career opportunities

Job hoppers end up with a set of new colleagues, mentors, and industry connections with every new job. As a result, job hoppers can build a wide professional network in a relatively short time, and this can be pretty helpful for their future jobs or business.

3. Offers potential for higher earnings and benefits negotiation

The biggest advantage that job-hopping can provide is the ability for career advancement in the shortest way possible.

Rather than hang around and hope for a promotion or more responsibility in their current role, job hoppers change quickly and enter other jobs with increased salaries, improved benefits, and more opportunities.

4. Enhances marketability through diverse skill development

Job hopping could well be a fast lane in acquiring diversified skills. From different tasks, challenges, and a learning environment, each new job presents opportunities to broaden your skill set.

Job Hopping Cons for Hiring Candidates

If you’re ambitious and enjoy new challenges, job hopping could be a useful strategy to fast-track your career. It’s not without its downsides though. Here are some of the things you should bear in mind.

1. Creates a perception of instability in some employers

Let's face facts, employers can potentially see job hoppers as candidates who are not committed or might leave the position not long after being recruited. And that leads to the hassle and cost of having to repeat the recruitment process and train someone else for the role.

You can understand why recruiters might be wary of someone with a lot of short-term employment history.

2. Misses out on long-term benefits like retirement plans

If you’re only hanging around in a role for two to three years, chances are you’re going to miss out on some of the longer-term benefits on offer.

Many companies reward loyalty and offer good benefits for long-term employees, which means enhanced pension schemes or share schemes only really begin to pay out after several years.

Plus, when thinking about planning your future, you’ll need to consider how things like Maternity or Paternity pay might be affected by short tenures.

3. Quick changes and limited experience could harm talent reputation

Job hopping can help you to develop a diverse skill set, but it can also leave some skill gaps. If a candidate frequently moves on before really getting to grips with a role, they can miss out on essential knowledge, including employee training, and developing a deeper understanding of the job.

This can be a red flag, especially if you’re looking for positions that require specialised knowledge or experience.

4. Brings challenges in cultural integration and relationship-building

Job hopping can expand your network, but it comes with at least a couple of downsides. With too much job hopping comes shallow relationships instead of deep, meaningful connections.

And, it goes without saying, that quitting a job under adverse circumstances can rub people the wrong way and potentially harm future opportunities.

Is Job Hopping Worth the Risk?

If you’re thinking about job hopping, here are some pointers to consider first.

1. Gauge how current role aligns with long-term career goals

Job hopping can be a useful fast track for short-term career development, but, at the same time, it can actually hinder long-term growth. Why? Well, employers might be nervous of promoting a job hopper to senior or management roles in fear that they will leave before making any significant contribution.

On the flip side, if you’ve been in your current job for a while and there are no signs of progression, it might be time to take a leap of faith and look for something that offers more potential for growth.

2. Assess the company’s financial stability and growth potential

Rather than jump at the first great package you’re offered, assess the new opportunity. For example, moving from an established business into an ambitious start-up could open up doors for extra responsibility and new challenges, but might not offer job security.

Look at the corporate revenue growth, profitability, and current standing in the market. A financially stable company can offer job security, good pay, and the opportunity to advance your career.

3. Evaluate the salary, benefits, and overall financial package

Job hopping can be an attractive way to quickly increase your salary. Don't just focus on the base salary though, make sure the overall package will leave you better off financially. Remember, in a new role, you might have longer to wait before you can expect a pay rise or bonuses.

Don’t overlook additional benefits that can quickly add up too, such as health insurance and paid time off might seem small in the overall picture, but they can significantly impact your overall expenses and savings.

4. Consider how the new role may impact work-life balance

If the new role will leave you better off financially, but dramatically change your work-life balance, you might want to consider if it’s really worth it.

Things like flexible working and remote working might not pay the bills, but they can make a big difference to your quality of life. Moving from flexible working to a role that requires you to be in the office 9-5, or involves a long commute, can quickly take its toll.

5. Determine if the company culture aligns with personal values

Beyond just looking at the job itself, think about whether it’s somewhere you really want to work. Look at how people within the business interact with each other, the company’s values, and how they treat their employees.

6. Consider the implications of frequent job changes on resume

Job hopping can be a red flag for employers, so you’ll need to be prepared to explain the moves you’ve made. Rather than just listing your job titles and dates on your resume, make sure to highlight your achievements. Show how you still made positive and meaningful contributions in a short time.

When preparing for interviews, be ready to explain your job changes so they appear to be part of a career journey on which you have grown and learned, with the strategic choices behind each move.

Recruitment Tips for Gauging Job-Hopping Candidate Potential

Recruiters, here is what you should be doing to evaluate and leverage job hoppers.

1. Analyse resume patterns and reasons for job changes

While it can be easy to quickly disregard job hoppers based on their resume alone, It’s worth taking the time to find out why your candidate appears to be swapping jobs so quickly.

Using tools like recruitment workflow automation can help handle routine tasks such as initial data collection and basic candidate assessments, freeing up time for recruiters to spend on individual candidates and getting into the reasons behind frequent job changes.

2. Check references for performance and reliability

Do your due diligence by checking references from past employers and colleagues. You’ll want to get a picture of their dedication, how they handle change, and if they deliver tangible results before moving on.

3. Ask interview questions about career goals and motivations

When hiring, ask candidates about their long-term career goals and how they can see themselves growing in your organisation. Any hesitation in the answer to this question may reveal volumes about their level of commitment in the future and compatibility with you.

4. Evaluate skills, contributions, and cultural fit

Does the job-hopper's diversity of experience fit into your company's culture and needs, or not? While it might feel like taking a risk hiring a job hopper, they can bring valuable new ideas and energy to your organisation.

Additionally, implementing a diversity sourcing strategy can help identify job hoppers from underrepresented backgrounds who bring unique perspectives and experiences.

5. Consider if their experiences align with company needs

Focus on potential skills and achievements that will be brought on board by a candidate. Job hoppers have typically seen a lot and can bring plenty of experience and fresh perspectives into your workforce.

Conclusion

Ultimately, whether you're hopping from one job to another or hiring a job hopper, the key is to focus on growth, adaptability, and the value each new experience brings.

For recruiters, the job hopper can bring a fresh new perspective and a wealth of experience with them. However, it’s crucial to understand the context behind frequent job changes and assess their potential for long-term contribution.

Author Bio

Natasha Thakkar brings over a decade of marketing expertise to her role as Content Marketing Manager at Oleeo, a tech company that specialises in producing recruitment software solutions. Skilled in lead generation and communication, Natasha shapes content that enhances Oleeo's brand and resonates with audiences. With experience handling global campaigns and an approach rooted in innovation and engagement, she excels in strategic campaigns, skillfully adapting to trends and connecting with audiences to optimise visibility. Connect with Natasha on LinkedIn.